How To Clean Cookie Sheets With Baked-On Grease (Using 5 Methods)

Cookie sheets are a must-have in a home or a standard kitchen. Else how would you bake your cookies and other baked goods if you don’t have a cookie sheet?

So do you own a cookie sheet? Or you do, but it is now brown instead of the normal silver color it should have been.

But have you ever cared enough to clean your cookie sheet?

If you are bothered that it is brownish, you should know that it became brown due to the baked-on grease that has gathered on the cookie sheet over time.

How To Clean Cookie Sheets With Baked On Grease

How to Clean Baked On Grease On Cookie Sheets

Now, if you have a lot of baked-on grease on your cookie sheet, you are going to have to learn how to clean your cookie sheet eventually.

As beautiful as your cookie sheet may be, something is unsettling about the fact that it never returns to its original color.

These cookie sheets can turn ineffective if the baked-on grease is not removed on time.

And so, if you’ve been researching the various ways to clean your cookie sheet, you must have possibly stumbled upon some methods demonstrated on some pages on how to clean the baked-on grease from your cookie sheet.

Some methods may have directed you to use some cleaning agents like ketchup, baking soda, and the rest to remove the baked-on grease.

So if you are familiar with baking soda or bicarbonate of soda as it is called, it can effectively remove every greasy mess.

This is because baking soda has a natural alkaline base which is great for breaking down grease. Even if the grease has been stuck for years, the baking soda will easily remove the grease.

If you combine baking soda with water, it will also enhance the cleaning.


How To Clean Your Cookie Sheet Using Different Methods

Baking Soda & Hydrogen peroxide; hydrogen peroxide is one of the strongest oxidizers that can help you in breaking up any long-term grease on your cookie sheet.

So instead of combining baking soda with white vinegar, if you want an easy process, you can use hydrogen peroxide to make your work easy.

Hydrogen peroxide works well against greasy mess. So you can mix the baking soda with hydrogen peroxide to get you a clean baking sheet.

So get steel wool to help you remove the grime. If your cookie sheet is greasy or scotch, Brite pads will do the work well.

Now to apply this method, you can create a paste-like solution using a few tablespoons of baking soda mixed with a few drops of hydrogen peroxide.

However, you can pour both the baking soda and the hydrogen peroxide on the affected area of the cookie sheet. Then begin scrubbing from there.

When you are done scrubbing, make a solution of warm water and liquid dish soap, then rinse the cookie sheet with warm soapy water to get you your desired result.

Cookie sheets can absorb a lot of heat because they have the work to deliver hot meals and sweet treats. However, even the most sensitive homemaker cannot avoid the baked-on greasy mess and burnt food particles as well.

And all these greasy stains and sticky sugars tend to add up over time if not cleaned. In fact, at some point, you may need to toss away your old cookie sheet and replace it with some other.

If your cookie sheet is still useful, read through this article for some natural cleaning tips that will help remove the baked-on grease.


Solutions to Clean Baked-on Grease From Your Cookie Sheets

There are some do-it-yourself methods that you can employ to clean your cookie sheets thoroughly. Some of these do-it-yourself solutions are; baking soda, white vinegar, and hydrogen peroxide.


1. Here is how to clean your cookie sheets with baking soda

Using the no-scrubbing solution is one of the easiest and best ways to clean the cookie sheets. You can start by pouring the boiling water into the cookie pan, then add a few tablespoons of baking soda.

Once you observe that the solution stops bubbling, allow the solution to sit for about an hour before you can now wipe the burnt-on debris away using a soft cloth.

You can now round up by rinsing the cookie sheet with some mild dish soap.

But if your baked-on greasy mess is so stubborn, you can soak the cookie sheet with a hot soapy mixture and one tablespoon of baking soda.

After soaking the cookie sheet for about an hour or overnight, you can now scrub away the grime or greasy stains. Just in case you have a non-stick cookie sheet, you can try to avoid applying pressure while scrubbing your cookie sheet.


2. Here is how to clean your cookie sheet using baking soda and white vinegar

If you have an extra tough greasy mess, you should use baking soda and vinegar to clean your sheets.

The baking soda is a perfect grease lifter, while the white vinegar is a natural acid that works well with a greasy mess.

So simply fill your kitchen sink with some hot water and pour a generous amount of baking soda and white vinegar, about a half cup each.

Then place the cookie sheet in the sink and allow it to soak for about 40 to 60 minutes.

Next, after 60 minutes, use a basic kitchen sponge to clean off the baked-on residue, then wash the pan thoroughly with mild liquid soap then allow it to dry thoroughly before use.

If you are using a non-stick cookie sheet, you may need to skip the vigorous scrubbing part to protect the nonstick coating.

However, baking soda and white vinegar can be used to clean the non-stick cookie sheet. Now cover the cookie sheet with two tablespoons of baking soda and about one cup of white vinegar.

Once the greasy mess is gone, you can now wash the cookie sheet with some liquid dish soap.

3. How To Clean Your Cookie Sheet With A Scouring Tool

To get your baked-on grease cookie sheet, you should use good scouring products so that you don’t under-wash or over-wash your cookie sheet to the point that the coating wears out.

So get a copper cloth or an aluminum foil to scrub away the burnt-on particles.

However, if you are using a non-stick cookie sheet, do not use the scouring tool because the silicone polyester coating is quite okay for keeping the food from sticking to the cookie sheet.

That means that the nonstick coating will be severely damaged if you decide to use a scouring sponge on your nonstick cookie sheet.


4. How To Clean Your Cookie Sheet With Hydrogen Peroxide

Hydrogen peroxide is not only used for medical use. So if you keep a bottle for the sake of health use, you should take it out of it and sprinkle it over your cookie sheet.

Then get a baking soda and sprinkle it over your cookie sheet.

Sprinkle the cookie sheet with another layer of baking soda, then allow it to sit for about two hours.

Then wipe off using a damp sponge after the time has elapsed. If the stain is still there, then repeat the process.

However, if you choose to use hydrogen peroxide, make sure you test it in a hidden spot. Now thoroughly rinse and wash the cookie sheet as soon as the treatment is complete.


5. How To Clean Cookie Sheet Using The Self-Cleaning Oven Method

You can decide to employ the self-cleaning method to clean the baked-on grease of your cookie sheet.

However, follow the manufacturer’s instructions if you must use the self-cleaning method.

So once the cleaning cycle is complete and your cookie sheets have cooled, then you can wash them with mild liquid soap and then dry them.

However, if the baked-on greasy mess is still on the cookie sheet and you have repeated the above method, it is time to get new cookie sheets.


Frequently Asked Questions

Is hydrogen peroxide good for cleaning your cookie sheet?

Yes. As long as you are done washing your cookie sheet with hydrogen peroxide, you can now rinse your cookie sheet using warm soapy water so that it can rinse off the hydrogen peroxide.

Can you use hydrogen peroxide to clean your nonstick cookie sheet?

Yes. As long as you don’t scrub the cookie sheet vigorously, then you are good to go. Your nonstick cookie sheet doesn’t need too much pressure while scrubbing else it will lose the coating.

What is the best cleaning agent to use in cleaning the stubborn greasy stains from your cookie sheet?

The best cleaning agent to use is hydrogen peroxide. This is because it is easy to use and quite effective.

What is the best natural cleaning agent to use on your cookie sheet?

You should consider using the baking soda and white vinegar mixture. The two cleaning agents are more effective when combined.



In conclusion, cleaning baked-on grease from your cookie sheet will help keep them clean and shiny. Also, it will help them remain durable for as long as you want until they naturally wear off.